www射-国产免费一级-欧美福利-亚洲成人福利-成人一区在线观看-亚州成人

Global EditionASIA 中文雙語Fran?ais
Business
Home / Business / Finance

Why Japan's 'balance sheet recession' won't hit China

By Lu Zhe and Liu Zibo | China Daily | Updated: 2023-07-31 09:25
Share
Share - WeChat
CAI MENG/CHINA DAILY

A significant increase in credit and extreme optimism led to the formation of Japan's economic bubble in the 1980s, which later ballooned due to a loose monetary policy, the pro-cyclical effect between financial and economic activities, and a sustained rally in land prices prompted by the land tax system.

In 1990, due to a tightening monetary policy and sharp declines in land and stock prices, the bubble began to pop. The Asian Financial Crisis of the late 1990s, coupled with post-bubble blues, worsened the business environment, with rising recessionary pressure on the Japanese real economy.

In 1991, the Bank of Japan adopted a raft of policy measures with the chief aim of defusing the potential insolvency risks of financial institutions. Meanwhile, it continued to execute a relaxed monetary policy.

Despite these, Japan's GDP growth in real terms has barely topped 3.5 percent since 1991, trailing other economies of the Group of Seven for most of the time. The effect of this policy mix can hardly be described as effective.

Japan suffered from sluggish economic growth and recession for a decade, a phenomenon dubbed as the "Lost Decade". However, in terms of actual economic growth, it is more appropriate to call it "Three Decades of Change".

To explain the failure of monetary policy and the reason why the Japanese economy was not growing, economist Richard C. Koo put forward the concept of "balance sheet recession" — a groundbreaking assessment from summarizing the shared experience of the United States and Japan.

The underlying logic behind the theory of a "balance sheet recession" was that the private sector undergoes great insolvency as a result of a plunge in asset values, including stock and land prices. Private businesses are committed to debt minimization rather than profit maximization. Therefore, the private sector — despite the constantly lower financing costs due to the easing monetary stance — will only raise funds to pay for outstanding debt, rather than scale up investment or consumption.

Unborrowed savings from this repayment of long-term debt will result in funds sitting idle in the financial sector, and aggregate demand will spiral downward, thus inducing deflation.

The GDP will continue to shrink until the private sector completely repairs its balance sheet or is no longer able to increase new savings. Since monetary policy has partially failed, fiscal stimulus may be the most forceful way to help businesses walk out of the "balance sheet recession".

In addition, due to the highly persistent "scarring effect", the private sector would be extra cautious about debt following a long and painful deleveraging process.

So, fiscal stimulus needs to be provided on an ongoing basis over the long term with well-focused tax and fee cuts to encourage the private sector to invest and consume.

China's case

China has not yet entered into a "balance sheet recession". This assessment is based on the analysis of the Japanese economy before and after the bursting of its economic bubble in the 1990s, and a discussion of the basic logic of "balance sheet recession" and relevant policy measures.

Home price filings and land sales, which are both led by the government, make China more capable of navigating asset price fluctuations.

As a result, the likelihood of private sector insolvency triggered by a sharp fall in asset prices has been weakened.

The overall downturn in the domestic real estate sector since 2021 has been a cause for concern. Yet, the country has a long-standing pattern of relying on expensive residential land grants to subsidize the relatively cheaper grants of commercial and industrial land.

Data from January to May this year show that the average sale price of residential, commercial, and industrial, mining and warehousing land was 7,598 yuan ($1,061), 2,720 yuan and 340 yuan per square meter, respectively.

According to macroeconomic data provider CEIC, private consumption contributed only 38 percent to China's GDP in 2021.

Unlike Japan's heavy reliance on the private sector to increase leverage and expand domestic demand prior to the bubble, China has not resorted to massive stimulus. So, the decline in residential land values from 2021 will not trigger a systemic "balance sheet recession" in the country.

Moreover, the main reason why Chinese residents rush to pay off loans ahead of schedule is because of a lack of investment products with high returns, not due to household insolvency.

For example, from January to end-May 2023, the number of equity hybrid funds with positive returns accounted for only 38 percent of all such funds.

Currently, the domestic economy is facing considerable pressure, including a middle-income trap, dampening overseas market demand, a rapidly aging population and government debt risk.

The authorities should leave ample space in advance to effectively maneuver fiscal policy as and when needed.

China's per capita GDP in 2022 exceeded 80,000 yuan, close to the high-income national standard set by the World Bank in 2021($12,695). A rise in labor costs may weigh down China's cost advantage in exports. Although the nation has a more complete industrial chain — a competitive edge that regions such as Southeast Asia will find difficult to catch up with in the short term — the middle-income trap remains a major concern.

But trade protectionism has gained ground in some Western countries lately, and China's exports face excessive entry barriers in overseas markets.

In addition, an aging population is a critical issue that China has to deal with.

By the end of 2021, there were 267.36 million elderly people aged 60 and above, accounting for 18.9 percent of the total population, up from 14.3 percent in 2012.

In general, consumption demand from the elderly group is lower than that of the young-adult group. The pressure on aggregate domestic demand brought about by an aging population and a declining birthrate needs high attention.

Besides, the risk of government debt, with a special focus on local government financing vehicles, needs to be addressed without delay.

Since 2021, as declining land transfer revenues continued to weaken government financial strength at the primary level, pressure on debt payment of local government financing vehicles in certain regions has been brought to the fore.

To resolve government debt in a market-oriented and rules-based manner, a method of leverage transfer could be employed. Any debt risk can be shared fairly among debtors and creditors, and the principle of "no bailout from the central government" should be strictly adhered to.

From a creditor's point of view, the net withdrawal of the non-banking portion of the bonds may be compensated by other local financial resources. What's more, hidden debt could be swapped and kept on the books to improve the financial sustainability of local governments.

Lu Zhe is chief macroeconomist and Liu Zibo is a macroeconomic analyst at Topsperity Securities. The views don't necessarily reflect those of China Daily.

Top
BACK TO THE TOP
English
Copyright 1995 - . All rights reserved. The content (including but not limited to text, photo, multimedia information, etc) published in this site belongs to China Daily Information Co (CDIC). Without written authorization from CDIC, such content shall not be republished or used in any form. Note: Browsers with 1024*768 or higher resolution are suggested for this site.
License for publishing multimedia online 0108263

Registration Number: 130349
FOLLOW US
CLOSE
 
主站蜘蛛池模板: 日韩成人免费一级毛片 | 亚洲精品国产国语 | 91香蕉国产线在线观看免费 | 国产精品免费看 | 亚洲天堂免费 | 国产中文字幕在线播放 | 中文字幕 亚洲精品 | 2020国产成人免费视频 | 韩国精品一区二区三区在线观看 | 久久国产亚洲欧美日韩精品 | 精品一区二区三区中文字幕 | 亚洲精品第五页 | 精品国产免费人成在线观看 | 亚洲日本在线观看 | 久草新 | 日产一区二区三区四区 | 精品视频在线视频 | 加勒比在线免费视频 | 99热久久国产精品免费观看 | 2021精品国产品免费观看 | 久久精品a | 亚洲精品一区二区三区四区 | 国产三级黄色 | 成人午夜视频在线播放 | 欧美性活一级视频 | 精品综合久久久久久蜜月 | 国产精品久久久久久久久免费 | 手机看片自拍自自拍日韩免费 | 国产美女动态免费视频 | 三级a毛片| 可以免费看黄的网站 | 免费视频精品一区二区三区 | 一级高清毛片免费a级高清毛片 | 91欧美精品综合在线观看 | 欧美在线一区二区三区不卡 | 美女张开大腿让男人桶 | 亚洲精品成人7777在线观看 | 亚洲aⅴ在线 | 一区二区三区网站在线免费线观看 | 欧美不卡视频 | 欧美黄色一级视屏 |