www射-国产免费一级-欧美福利-亚洲成人福利-成人一区在线观看-亚州成人

Zhu Yuan

TV serials are for fun, books for knowledge

By Zhu Yuan (China Daily)
Updated: 2010-09-22 08:11
Large Medium Small

A popular discussion in the media and on the Internet nowadays is whether a new TV serial based on A Dream of Red Mansions reflects the spirit of the classic novel more than the old version made in 1987. Is such a discussion necessary?

The discussion reminds me of Neil Portman's book Amusing Ourselves to Death. Portman firmly believes that TV is not an effective medium of transmitting ideas. Instead, it confounds serious issues with entertainment.

I think TV serials play the same role that storytellers did in the past. Storytellers used to attract listeners for their ability to bring alive the complicated plots and suspense in a tale. TV serials do the same with viewers today. And both have made it possible for the audience to know about history and the ethics they need to follow in their daily lives.

But there's a big difference between the two. TV serials fill a person's room for imagination with images, whereas storytellers (as well as novelists and short-story writers) leave the imagination to listeners (and readers).

Strangely, the discussion on A Dream of Red Mansions is revolving around how loyal the new TV series is to the core spirit of the book. This is like asking whether mashed potatoes mixed with chicken stock taste like simply mashed potatoes.

A book is for reading and a TV serial is for watching. They are two completely different things. A book requires more time and concentration and sometimes enough meditation to appreciate its subtleties and intricacies. It may even require a reader to read some portions more than once to read between the lines. Above all, a book gives full play to a reader's imagination.

A TV series, on the other hand, is for entertainment. More often, viewers do not need to use their brains. Quite a number of viewers often snack and chat with family members or friends while watching TV, which is something a serious reader would never do while reading a book.

No wonder, Portman says TV serials and programs confound serious issues with entertainment. They trivialize, even demean, political discourses by making them less about ideas and more about images.

Every person who reads a novel or short story has to use his/her imagination. He/she can visualize a character in many ways and dream up a whole lot of ideas about a scene. This is the greatest difference between reading a novel or short story and watching it being told (or retold) on TV with the help of sound and visuals.

There is no benchmark for judging whether a TV serial is true to the spirit of a literary work. Any attempt to do so would be gobbledygook. Or, at best it would be the serial makers' efforts to attract more viewers to their production and earn more revenue.

Watching either the new TV serial or the 1987 version of A Dream of Red Mansions, a person will never be able appreciate the literary value of the novel, which has been acclaimed as one of the four classics of the country.

I agree with Portman that TV is not an effective way of providing education, because it provides only top-down information, rather than the interaction necessary to maximize learning. This holds true for intellectuals. But I would like to say one thing: TV does provide a kind of education for the illiterates in the same way that opera and storytelling did before films and TV programs became part of modern life.

The author is a senior editor with China Daily and can be reached at zhuyuan@chinadaily.com.cn.

(China Daily 09/22/2010 page4)

主站蜘蛛池模板: 在线国产一区二区 | 久久久精品国产免费观看同学 | 成人中文字幕一区二区三区 | 国产在线精品一区二区高清不卡 | 日韩毛片免费在线观看 | 日韩1级片| 亚洲性xx| 性欧美另类老妇高清 | 日本成人免费在线观看 | 国产大片在线观看 | 亚洲精品亚洲人成毛片不卡 | 日韩国产免费 | 手机看片在线 | 久久99国产乱子伦精品免 | 大学生一级一片第一次免费 | 久草在线视频在线观看 | 欧美激情亚洲色图 | 黄色大片三级 | 99综合在线 | 国产啪精品视频网免费 | 亚洲一区在线观看视频 | 欧美日韩综合高清一区二区 | 欧美一级淫片免费观看 | 亚洲 中文 欧美 日韩 在线人 | 欧美亚洲日本国产 | 中文一区在线观看 | 国产波多野结衣中文在线播放 | 波多野结衣在线不卡 | 亚洲精品久久99久久 | 男人干女人逼 | 国产综合视频在线观看一区 | 精品韩国主播福利视频在线观看一 | 久久久久久久久久久观看 | 狠狠综合久久久久综合小说网 | 一区二区三区免费视频观看 | 在线观看国产精品入口 | 国产高清免费在线 | 欧美成人午夜做爰视频在线观看 | 全国男人的天堂天堂网 | 香港aa三级久久三级 | 在线看欧美成人中文字幕视频 |